[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

keying by identity in dict and set

On Sun, Oct 20, 2019 at 7:57 PM Peter Otten <__peter__ at> wrote:
> Steve White wrote:
> >
> > The point is, I don't think __eq__() is ever called in a situation as
> > described in my post, yet the Python documentation states that if
> > instances are to be used as keys, it must not be used to determine if
> > non-identical instances are equivalent.
> What else should be used if not __eq__()? Where in the docs did you you see
> such a statement?
Nothing.  Nowhere.

As I said, it appears that if __hash__ returns values from the id()
function, no collision ever occurs, so there is tie to break in a lookup, so
in particular there is no need for the heuristic of calling __eq__.

And again, the problem here is that the documentation is a little weak
on just how these things really interact.  We're having to guess, experiment,
and even look at C code of the Python implementations.

> The only limitation for a working dict or set is that for its keys or
> elements
> (1) a == b implies hash(a) == hash(b)
> (2) a == a
> Does your custom class violate one of the above?
Yes.  It's all in the original post, including code.
Give it a shot!